I'm changing things up a bit here. I'm having a heck of a time getting predictable oxygenation with the oxygen stone. It's just not that consistent. So, the new idea is instead of oxygenating the wort, lets try oxygenating the fermenter head space.
I picked up one of these drill mixers things. It's kind of spiffy. It's folds down to fit inside the carboy and fans out when spinning. This thing really whips up the liquid. I did some tests with water.
Water just splashing into the fermenter from the faucet came in around 3-3.5 ppm. Note you brewers who just "fan" the wort into the fermenter. That's probably not doing the job. I then used my cordless drill at ~600 RPMs to stir. I put a stopper on the stirrer to seal up the fermenter. The thinking here is to avoid sucking in a bunch of air to contaminate the beer, but also an attempt to control the O2 levels. I don't want to get a bunch of O2 into solution to just have it degas out if I can help it.
After about two minutes, I got about 8 ppm in the water, which is about spot on. This should be perfect for ales. Note that this is just water, and could be lower with wort. With that stopper holding things back, I think the head space only holds enough O2 to do about 6-7 ppm, so I did it twice one minute each. Between spins, I pulled out the stirrer. That seemed to get me my 8 ppm the quickest.
I then emptied the carboy and started again. This time I put the O2 hose into the neck of the carboy and gave it 10 psi for 15 seconds. I stirred for 30 seconds, and it was 20+ ppm. That was fast...
I tried few more times, and came down to using 5 psi for just a second or two w/ 30 seconds of stirring gave me 12 ppm. Perfect. If I did the same spurt of O2, but did 8 ppm with just air first, that gave me 14 ppm. I did this a few more times and was pretty consistent. Again, this will likely change with wort, but I think I've got my ball park solution.
What's remarkable is how very little O2 is needed to get oxygenation. Just a spurt is all it takes.
Oh, and this thing is great for cleaning kegs too! I fill with cleaner, swirl it up and let it sit.
04-15-08 UPDATE: I used this on wort tonight. Two batches of German Pils at 1.044. I used just aeration for 2 minutes, and that gave me 8.3 ppm. I then gave the second fermenter my 1 second whiff of 5 psi O2, and stirred for 30 seconds. That gave me 11.6 ppm. I wanted to go a just a little higher, but I called it good. Next time maybe try two seconds of O2.
I'm pretty happy with this solution. It's pretty consistent and gets what I want on my first try. No fussing around.
04/29/08 UPDATE: I ran this on the recent Flanders Red, which was about 1.068 or so. I got 7.7 ppm, so we're starting to see the affects of original gravity on dissolved O2. At this point, the yeast should also have higher O2 requirements, so we have inverse conditions working against us. For my own brewing, I might call 1.065-1.070 the break point for aeration on ales. From there, I may want to start giving some O2 to the head space.
06/29/08 UPDATE: Just a quick update on the technique. I'm having great results doing this. Since I first tried this, I've got 13 batches in. What I've settled in with is I shoot for 12-16 ppm on all beers, just to make things easy. I'm not seeing anything negative on ales or lower gravity ales at those levels, so I'm going with a unified technique. What I do is I give the wort 3 seconds of O2 at 5 psi, then mix for 20 seconds or so. That gives me somewhere between 14-15, with some variations on wort gravity.

Recent Comments